In today’s collectibles market, few concepts trigger as much immediate skepticism as “digital repacks.” Over the last few years, the hobby has been flooded with mystery box platforms, instant-rip apps, and digitized card products. The sector has quickly built a reputation for opaque algorithms, predatory buyback fees, and boxes crammed with hard-to-move filler.
I’ve been burned by repacks myself, and recently. Just last month, after a modest winning streak at a casino, I decided to test my luck on a physical baseball card repack machine. The cost was $150, plus a $30 service fee on top of that. The card I pulled was ultimately worth about $5. I left thinking I would have been much happier losing that money at the roulette table. That kind of lingering frustration is all too common, and with the sheer number of new repack startups entering the hobby, trust is at an all time low.
“It seems like there’s a new one of these launching every single week,” says Mike Katz, Co-Founder and CEO of Trove. “Most of it is like AI slop put together, and it’s not done very well. But there are also real businesses being built, and it’s important to discern between the two”.
Trove is trying to prove that the digital repack model doesn’t have to be a predatory cash grab. By pairing digital pack openings with authenticated, physical cards securely stored in the PSA Vault, the platform is attempting to rethink the entire experience from the ground up.
Bringing Social Play to Ripping
Digital pack ripping has historically been an isolated, single-player experience. Rather than trying to sanitize the inherent thrill of the rip, Trove is using its new Pack Battles feature to bring a genuine social element back to online collecting.
The multiplayer mode lets users send direct invites to friends or match up with strangers in head-to-head battles, where both players open a pack and the highest-value pull takes home both physical slabs. But it’s also built as a spectator sport, anyone can open the Trove app and watch live Pack Battles unfold in real-time, no purchase necessary.
While losing a battle can certainly be crushing, especially if your opponent walks away with a grail you just revealed, Trove’s underlying mechanics help keep the stakes fair. Because every pack comes with a strict 50% value floor and a 100% Fair Market Value buyback guarantee, the ecosystem ensures that even in a head-to-head environment, the baseline card value remains transparent and real rather than turning into a total wipeout.
Katz emphasizes that this multiplayer format isn’t meant to replace traditional solo openings. “Pack Battles is effectively a multiplayer mode. It doesn’t replace the core experience, it augments it”.
Rewarding the Long-Term Collector
Most repack platforms solely profit on transaction volume, which incentivizes rapid flipping rather than actually building a collection. Trove is attempting to shift this paradigm through its industry-first Collection Dividends program. Instead of punishing collectors for holding onto their cards, Trove pays users an annual yield, a minimum of 2% annually, paid monthly in Trove Cash, simply for keeping their physical cards in their virtual PSA Vault within the Trove app.
“There’s been so much innovation and celebration around the transaction, but the collector has kind of been forgotten about,” Katz reflects. “We want to continue to invest in the end-to-end collector experience. If we’re going to talk it, we’re going to walk it”.
Fixing Transparency and Curation
Underpinning these features is an effort to tackle the “black box” odds problem inherent in digital pack openings. Trove utilizes a technical “provably fair” standard, ensuring odds and outcomes are mathematically verifiable rather than relying on blind trust. To back that up, Trove will shortly be opening up its API so users can independently simulate and query the data to prove the decks aren’t stacked.
“For us, it starts with establishing a baseline of provable fairness—capital P, capital F. All of the outcomes are verifiable,” explains Katz.
Additionally, the platform addresses the issue of “junk” filler slabs by actively curating its inventory with human buyers rather than automated systems. Trove’s team physically sources cards from card shows, vault bids, and major auction houses like Alt and Goldin, focusing on secondary market demand and insert appeal. And when a user wants to liquidate a pull, removing the hidden “service fees” common on competing apps means their instant buyback offer is truly friction-free.
“Other guys say it’s 90%, but then there’s an additional service fee, and it just feels like a tax every time you’re trying to find the cards that you actually love,” Katz notes. “We remove that because we want to remove the friction”.
A Shift in the Market
Thinking back to that casino floor, the reason I left feeling burned wasn’t just that I lost money, it was the feeling that the game was rigged, the $30 service fee was predatory, and a $5 card on a $180 total layout was an insult.
As the repack industry continues to expand, the platforms that survive long-term will likely be the ones that eliminate that exact feeling by prioritizing transparency and accountability. Any chance-based product carries inherent risk, and collectors should always enter the arena with clear expectations. However, by eliminating hidden service fees, setting strict 50% value floors, and opening up their math to public scrutiny, Trove is building actual guardrails against the worst impulses of the repack market. Whether their model becomes the new industry standard remains to be seen, but it proves that a mystery pack doesn’t have to leave you wishing you’d walked over to the roulette table instead.
Pack Battles are available now in the Trove app.
What are you thoughts? Let us know on Mantel.
